Stablecoins have become exceptionally popular in the market because they are meant to retain a stable value by being pegged to a reserve asset like the US dollar. While these two assets have the same aim of giving stability to the volatile world of crypto, they are on different ends of the governance, transparency, and regulatory compliance spectrum. In this article, I will explain howτσ both USDT and USDC maintain their peg to the dollar from a mechanical standpoint and show in deep detail how each one keeps their peg to the dollar.
Estimated reading time: 7 minutes
Table of Contents
The Mechanics of Stablecoins: Pegging to the US Dollar
Cryptocurrencies created with the intention to maintain price stability by binding value to a certain fiat currency or other valuables are known as the stablecoins. These stablecoins are collateralized as per the values which determine the value of these stablecoins, and this is on a system where the issuers hold reserves in the form of fiat currency, government short term debt or any low risk asset.
Most issuers’ reserve management strategies play a large factor in determining how stablecoins retain their peg. Historically, the reserves of the stablecoin have been hard to verify with transparency for a company behind it, that is, for Tether Limited, the company behind USDT.
While Tether states that USDT has the full backing and is 1:1 backed by US dollars or equivalent assets, the history of giving out insufficient audits has made people doubt the reserves of Tether. In contrast, operations of USDC, which is issued by Circle in partnership with Coinbase, are subject to more strict regulatory regimes. Regularity of third-party audits takes place on Circle so that we know that every single USDC is 100% fully backed by reserves, providing greater transparency and trust within the financial ecosystem.
Issuers, Governance, and Transparency
The Stablecoin issuer’s role is very important in the stability and governance of this coin. Tether Limited is a company that earlier had its origins in Hong Kong, but that maintains close ties with the Bitfinex exchange, which is the issuer of USDT. The relation between Tether and the US dollar has also resulted in some doubt over Tether’s transparency and how it will comply with regulation. Critics for many years criticized Tether for not displaying clear assets that back USDT and raised the question if the stablecoin can maintain its value in the case of market stress.
On the other hand, USDC was created by a US-based company called Circle and cooperated with Coinbase. Part of this partnership is that USDC will be subject to a higher standard of regulatory oversight and will be operating fully compliant with U.S. regulations. Basically, Circle is putting out monthly reserve attestations and annual audits performed by third-party firms, which have a much higher level of transparency than Tether. These audits ensure that every USDC is backed by reserves, many of which consist of US dollars and U.S. Treasury securities. This transparency gives users and institutions that rely on USDC to have confidence in its stability and security.
Regulatory Compliance and Legal Landscape
Regulatory compliance is a topic that both USDT and USDC have been receiving the attention of global regulators, however, USDC seems to have a clearer regulatory compliance path because of its alignment with U.S. regulatory standards. As far as stablecoins including USDT and USDC are concerned, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has declared that they do not fall under the category of securities since they are pegged to a stable asset and backed by reserves. By making this decision, some of the regulatory uncertainty surrounding stablecoins is removed, and that path is paved for further institutional adoption of the asset.
Controversy around reserve management practices has done nothing but tarnish Tether’s reputation, however, among USDC, it is an attractive play for institutional investors and companies that need a more regulatory-compliant stablecoin. The USDC has made the asset more secure, predictable and a more attractive choice for users in the regulated markets due to audits by USDC of regulatory transparency and compliance with US Treasury guidelines for stablecoins. The popularity of Ether would be on cryptocurrency exchanges it is a trading pair for many cryptocurrencies.
However, USDC has managed to make a name for itself in the space of decentralized finance (DeFi) and for being the stablecoin of choice for institutions and businesses. USDC’s adoption isn’t as big or as widely adopted as USDT, which hasn’t really seen the same level of adoption by financial institutions and enterprise-level solutions. Integration of USDC into traditional finance including payment processors and banking applications shows wider adoption of a stable, compliant, and transparent digital asset by the community. Both USDT and USDC are well to rise up to the occasion of decentralized finance, they’re being used as a source of yield, to participate in lending and borrowing, or used as collateral in smart contracts.
Blockchain Networks and Liquidity
The presence of the stablecoin on different blockchain networks is one of the critical factors that determine its success. In addition to Bitcoin, also operates on various blockchain platforms such as Ethereum, Tron, Binance Smart Chain, and Solana, USDT can be used as a store of value on the rest of the top 100 crypto coins. As USDT is available on a very wide variety of different blockchains, this broad cross-chain availability is what guarantees that USDT has high liquidity for USDT on all these ecosystems and thus you are easily able to transfer assets between platforms and have USDT attached to all these deployments of all these different blockchain-based applications.
Also similar, USDC is also supported across several blockchains including Ethereum, Solana, Polygon, and so on. While USDC’s presence is growing, it is not present on all blockchain networks in as much of a capacity as USDT is. The availability of networks differs, which may affect the amount of ease users will have in exchanging or using their coins on different platforms. Other than USDC, USDT has a larger presence across blockchain ecosystems, giving traders and users more options in moving assets faster. However, USDC is playing catch-up in terms of blockchain integration.
A key metric in evaluating the importance of a stablecoin in the entire cryptocurrency market is market capitalization. Currently, USDT is the largest stablecoin by market cap and is circulating with over $80 billion. The reason is, that it’s been adopted and used in pretty much all of the available exchanges and trading pairs.
USDC, despite being behind USDT, USDC is the second largest stablecoin by market cap ($40 billion) after it. Not only has this steadily increased its market share, but as more institutions and regulated financial services integrate USDC into their operations, it has also drawn those audiences to the mint. The top choice for transparency reasons and a regulatory compliant stablecoin, USDC has a stake in the second largest stablecoin’s position.
Risks and Challenges
Although USDT and USDC have different risks and challenges, they are prone to them. Major risks for USDT stem from the worsening questions regarding their reserve’s transparency, which stems from past controversies in times when the coin was being scrutinized by regulators. Questions have been raised about Tether’s ability to meet its obligations in the event of a large USDT redemption for U.S. dollars, because of the lack of independent, detailed audits.
On the other hand, the ability that USDC faces having a much lower stake in its reserve management is that it can be affected by market fluctuations and regulatory changes. While USDC’s compliance with U.S. regulations is positive, the regulatory uncertainty in the cryptocurrency space could restrict USDC’s long-term growth. Secondly, USDC’s operations in the traditional financial system can be subject to stricter regulatory requirements, depending on how it becomes more and more integrated.
Regulatory developments, institutional adoption and growing demand for decentralized financial products will shape the future of stablecoins. Therefore, USDT, which has high liquidity and widepread adoption, is most likely to be a force to be reckoned with in the cryptocurrency market. While USDC is quite transparent and regulated, in terms of being a stablecoin, it seems to be poised to grow for the long run.
With the development of the stablecoin market, USDT and USDC will have an important role in transaction transactions, investment investment, and financial products in the cryptocurrency field. That being said, as frameworks around stablecoins become more defined, the market could tilt in USDC’s favor, or at least that’s what many believe. USDT, USDC serves an integral function, and are needed to maintain stability in the unstable market.
